Case Note: Samsumg Electronics (UK) Limited v Apple Inc. [2012] EWHC 1882 Pat – Sweeny Legal

This case provides a very interesting illustration of how a court will approach community design rights infringement.

These cases are supposed to be simple, however it is the evidence is often complex and very detailed.

The High Court considered the following elements [1-7] of the Apple design, which Apple claimed to be similar to, Samsung’s copying of the Apple design:-

1. a rectangular, symmetrical slab with 4 evenly, slightly rounded corners;

2. a flat transparent surface;

3. a very thin rim of constant width and flush with the front surface;

4. a rectangular display screen surrounded by a plain border of constant width;

5. a substantially flat rear surface which curves upwards at the sides;

6. a very thin impression with curved sides as in 5;

7. Overall a design of extreme simplicity without feature which specify orientation.

The High Court noted the design was both simple and striking.

The design was one in which any user would want to pick up.

A very cool design. Indeed.

The design is designed to be hand held.

Introducing the Virtual Solicitor Service from Sweeny Legal in Wollongong

Tomorrow’s Lawyer Today – Tracy Sweeny at Sweeny Legal and Associates

Not-For-Profit Disability Law Advice available – I am willing to help others and share the knowledge I have acquired as a parent, advocating for disability rights over the past 20 years.

Proactive Intellectual Property Law, Commercial Law and Brand Licensing Advise in person at your business address and/or via Skype or FaceTime and save time.

There is no need to come to a law office.

SweenyLegal-Reversed Brandsworth Licensing logoSweenyLegal-Logo copy

Commitment, Integrity, Competence and Fixed Fees

Phone: 4228 1864

eFax: 4204 1684


Skype: SweenyLegal


Contact Sweeny Legal

Leave a comment

Filed under Applications Licensing, Designs Law, Intellectual Property Law, Patent Law, Trade Marks Law

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s